Offense
| Position | First | Second | Third |
|---|---|---|---|
| WR | Zach Pascal | ||
| LT | Anthony Castonzo | Le'Raven Clark | |
| LG | Quenton Nelson | ||
| C | Ryan Kelly | Evan Boehm | Josh Andrews |
| RG | Mark Glowinski | Evan Boehm | |
| RT | Braden Smith | Joe Haeg | |
| TE | Mo Alie-Cox | ||
| WR | T.Y. Hilton | Chester Rogers | Daurice Fountain |
| QB | Andrew Luck | Jacoby Brissett | |
| TE | Eric Ebron | ||
| RB | Marlon Mack | Nyheim Hines | Jordan Wilkins Jonathan Williams |
Defense
| Position | First | Second | Third |
|---|---|---|---|
| DE | Tyquan Lewis | Kemoko Turay | |
| NT | Margus Hunt | Grover Stewart | |
| UT | Denico Autry | ||
| DE | Jabaal Sheard | Al-Quadin Muhammad | |
| WLB | Darius Leonard | Matthew Adams | |
| MLB | Anthony Walker | Ahmad Thomas | |
| SAM | Zaire Franklin | ||
| CB | Kenny Moore II | Quincy Wilson | Chris Milton |
| FS | Malik Hooker | George Odum | |
| SS | Clayton Geathers | ||
| CB | Pierre Desir | Nate Hairston |
Special Teams
| Position | First | Second | Third |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | Rigoberto Sanchez | ||
| PK | Adam Vinatieri | ||
| H | Rigoberto Sanchez | ||
| LS | Luke Rhodes | ||
| KR | Zach Pascal | Chester Rogers | Nyheim Hines |
| PR | Chester Rogers | Zach Pascal | T.Y. Hilton |