Pro Football Focus this week released their 2025 All-Pro Team, and two Colts players received recognition: cornerback Sauce Gardner was named to the first team, and guard Quenton Nelson was named to the second team.
Gardner, who joined the Colts in Week 10 via a trade with the New York Jets, appeared in four games for the Colts. He played 100 percent of the defensive snaps in his first two games (Weeks 10 and 12) before sustaining a calf injury early in Week 13 that left him inactive and/or limited for the remainder of the games. Gardner registered a total of 16 tackles and three passes defensed this season for the Colts and finished the season ranked 10th among cornerbacks in PFF's overall grade (76.9).
Nelson, who started all 17 games for the Colts in 2025, finished this season ranked fourth among starting guards in Pro Football Focus' overall grade (84.5) and run block grade (84.3). He played 100 percent of the Colts' offensive snaps in eight of his 17 starts, and earlier this season was named to his eighth Pro Bowl.
