2020 Free Agency: Colts.com's Best Of The Rest

NFL Free Agency came in with a roar a couple weeks ago and has now settled down quite a bit. The Indianapolis Colts have made some productive moves, but there are still players left on the market. Who are the best of the rest of the players still available who might suit the Colts?


The analysis from those producing content on Colts.com does not necessarily represent the thoughts of the Indianapolis Colts organization. Any conjecture, analysis or opinions formed by Colts.com content creators is not based on inside knowledge gained from team officials, players or staff.

INDIANAPOLIS — The Indianapolis Colts started off the new NFL league year with a bang a couple weeks ago, making some significant moves both in the trade and free agent markets.

Free agency buzz across the league has died down a bit since then, but there are still plenty of quality players left to be signed.

Before we get into that, here is a look at the Colts' in-house free agents who are still left on the market, grouped into what type of free agent each player is (unrestricted, restricted, exclusive rights):

UFA — S Clayton Geathers, WR Dontrelle Inman, WR Chester Rogers, DE Jabaal Sheard, K Adam Vinatieri, RB Jonathan Williams

RFA — CB Briean Boddy-Calhoun, WR Marcus Johnson

ERFA — WR Daurice Fountain

Since free agency began, the moves that the Colts have made have transformed what their roster now needs.

Dating back to late in the 2019 season, the Colts have retained their own players in tight end Mo Alie-Cox, offensive tackle Anthony Castonzo, tight end Jack Doyle, kicker Chase McLaughlin and wide receiver Zach Pascal, but they have also brought in some excellent new pieces in defensive tackle DeForest Buckner, quarterback Philip Rivers, defensive tackle Sheldon Day and cornerback Xavier Rhodes.

Due to not only the volume, but the reported cost, of those deals, any players that the Colts may still be in the market for are likely not going to be of the big-ticket variety, so they may be looking at more modest options.

Looking ahead, we present the second edition of our Colts.com 2020 Free Agency Big Board. Rather than a typical big board in which players are ranked, we present you our top 20 available free agents specifically for the Colts, listed alphabetically.

Table inside Article
Jahleel AddaeSafety30Houston TexansThe Colts need depth behind Malik Hooker, Khari Willis and George Odum at safety, and Addae is good enough to be a starter if needed.
Geronimo AllisonWide Receiver26Green Bay PackersA part-time starter for the Packers, Allison would fit perfectly with the Colts. They need depth at the position, and he's got nice size at 6-3, 202.
Antoine BetheaSafety36New York GiantsOne of the best late-round finds of the last 15 years, the Colts could call home the safety who won a Super Bowl with them as a rookie. Providing leadership to a young Colts secondary could be invaluable.
Jaron BrownWide Receiver30Seattle SeahawksAt 6-3, 204 pounds, Brown could fit the mold as the long, big-bodied receiver that Rivers has always had and the Colts are interested in.
Morgan BurnettSafety31Cleveland BrownsThe versatile veteran safety could provide depth for the Colts in multiple spots in multiple formations.
Charles ClayTight End31Arizona CardinalsThe Colts could use a proven veteran pass-catcher at tight end alongside Jack Doyle and Mo Alie-Cox.
Vinny CurryEdge Defender32Philadelphia EaglesWith Jabaal Sheard still out on the market, the Colts could still use a depth at strong-side defensive end.
Javien ElliottCornerback27Carolina PanthersWe saw how much the Colts' passing game struggled with Kenny Moore II injured late in 2019. Elliott could provide depth in the slot and outside.
Markus GoldenEdge Defender29New York GiantsAgain, the Colts could use a little more depth at defensive end, and Golden has two 10-sack seasons on his résumé.
Rashard HigginsWide Receiver26Cleveland BrownsAt 6-1, 198, Higgins could be a decent-size target for the Colts. He was one of quarterback Baker Mayfield's favorite targets in Cleveland.
James HurstOffensive Lineman28Baltimore RavensThe Plainfield, Ind., native would be a good replacement for Joe Haeg, as he has starting experience at both tackle and guard.
Dion JordanEdge Defender30Oakland RaidersThe long, athletic edge defender could help provide depth for the Colts and give them a nice second wave on the defensive line.
Josh KlineOffensive Lineman30Minnesota VikingsMany fans and media thought Kline deserved more time in Minnesota, so he should resurface elsewhere quickly to compete for a starting guard spot.
Benson MayowaEdge Defender29Oakland RaidersAnother depth piece at edge, Mayowa has been a productive contributor to his teams' defensive fronts for several seasons now.
Pernell McPheeEdge Defender31Baltimore RavensYou guessed it, another defensive end. McPhee's been productive for a long time, registering five seasons in his career with at least four sacks, and six seasons with at least five tackles for loss.
Paul RichardsonWide Receiver28Washington RedskinsIf Richardson's health checks out, Colts quarterback Philip Rivers could get a lengthy, contested-catch maestro here.
Logan RyanCornerback29Tennessee TitansAgain, the Colts could use depth at slot corner, and Ryan could go above and beyond that. He's not the most fleet of foot, but he's versatile, tough and dependable.
Luke StockerTight End32Atlanta FalconsReliable as a blocker and pass-catcher, Stocker would be a perfect third member of the Colts' tight end group with Doyle and Alie-Cox.
Delanie WalkerTight End36Tennessee TitansOne of the most versatile and reliable tight ends of his era, Walker likely doesn't have much time left in the league. He's only played in eight games the last two seasons due to injury, so if his health looks good then he'll be a good second or third tight end option for interested teams.
Tavon WilsonSafety30Detroit LionsLast on the list is yet another depth option at safety. Wilson isn't afraid to stick out and make the tackle, averaging 70 per season over the last four years, also adding 15 tackles for loss, three interceptions, one forced fumble, four recoveries and five sacks.

Related Content

2023 Season Tickets On Sale Now!

2023 Season Tickets On Sale Now!

Our opponents are set! Secure the best seats & best benefits for next season, and be there live for exciting matchups against the Pittsburgh Steelers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers and more of the NFL's best opponents. Request more info or view our 3D Seat Viewer below!