Colts Trade for Sauce Gardner | Instant Reaction

Casey Vallier and Bill Brooks hop on to discuss the Colts making a trade to acquire cornerback Sauce Gardner from the New York Jets in exchange for first-round picks in 2026 and 2027, plus wide receiver Adonai Mitchell. Gardner is a 2-Time 1st-Team All-Pro and was NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year in 2022.

Casey Vallier and Bill Brooks discuss what went into the Colts' 27-20 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 9. They begin by highlighting a couple of impressive things from the Colts defense (2:54),  and Michael Badgley's two 50-plus yard field goals (9:26), as well as Alec Pierce's continued growth and reliability (12:16). They offer some perspective on the Colts' second loss of the season (15:18) before briefly previewing the Colts' Week 10 game in Berlin (19:32).

Casey Vallier and Bill Brooks sit down to go over everything that went into the Colts' 38-14 win over the Tennessee Titans, dominated by Jonathan Taylor's second consecutive three-touchdown game. The duo examine just how strong the Colts offense is (2:20) and how productive Taylor continues to be (6:15), as well as Daniel Jones' steadiness in the pocket (11:28). They also highlight Michael Pittman Jr.'s big day (13:25) and some impressive plays by the defense to secure the win (18:35).

Casey Vallier and Bill Brooks break down the Colts' 38-24 win over the Los Angeles Chargers at SoFi Stadium, starting with Jonathan Taylor's third three-touchdown performance of the season (2:26). Then they dive into how Daniel Jones is leading such an efficient and versatile offense (8:36), how the Colts' defense hung in to find a way to make big plays to help win the game (17:40) and two big plays by Grover Stewart and Ameer Abdullah (24:35).

Casey Vallier and Bill Brooks discuss how the Colts beat the Arizona Cardinals in a tense, hard-fought 31-27 victory to improve to 5-1. They analyze Josh Downs and Jonathan Taylor's impressive days and the continued efficiency of the Colts' offense, as well as how the defense battled through injuries to embody the "next man up" mentality.

Casey Vallier and Bill Brooks break down yet another impressive Colts win, in which Jonathan Taylor scored three touchdowns and Daniel Jones continued to prove how well-equipped he is to lead the Colts offense. The duo also look at how the defense held the Las Vegas Raiders to just six points in the 40-6 victory, how the Colts are continuing to develop their identity as a powerful and efficient offense and more.

Casey Vallier and Bill Brooks take a look at the penalties and self-inflicted wounds that played a large part in the Colts' first loss of the 2025 season to the Los Angeles Rams. The pair breaks down what the Colts can improve upon going forward, while also taking time to recognize Tyler Warren's first career touchdown and other impactful players in all three phases of the game on Sunday.

Casey Vallier and Bill Brooks break down the many highlights from the Colts' dominant 41-20 win over the Titans, including Kenny Moore II's pick-six and Jonathan Taylor's three touchdowns. They examine Daniel Jones' proven ability to throw the ball downfield, the impressive showing by the Colts' defensive line, take a look at the AFC South standings and more.