| Colts.com Mock Draft | Craig Kelley | Kevin Bowen | |
| 1. |  | Jadeveon Clowney DE, South Carolina | Jadeveon Clowney DE, South Carolina |
| 2. |  | Sammy Watkins WR, Clemson | Greg Robinson OT, Auburn |
| 3. |  | Khalil Mack LB, Buffalo | Johnny Manziel QB, Texas A&M |
| 4. |  | Johnny Manziel QB, Texas A&M | Sammy Watkins WR, Clemson |
| 5. |  | Jake Matthews OT, Texas A&M | Blake Bortles QB, Central Florida |
| 6. |  | Greg Robinson OT, Auburn | Jake Matthews OT, Texas A&M |
| 7. |  | Mike Evans WR, Texas A&M | Mike Evans WR, Texas A&M |
| 8. |  | Blake Bortles QB, Central Florida | Teddy Bridgewater QB, Louisville |
| 9. |  | Eric Ebron TE, North Carolina | Khalil Mack OLB, Buffalo |
| 10. |  | Ha Ha Clinton-Dix S, Alabama | Eric Ebron TE, North Carolina |
| 11. |  | Teddy Bridgewater QB, Louisville | Anthony Barr OLB, UCLA |
| 12. |  | Taylor Lewan OT, Michigan | C.J. Mosley ILB, Alabama |
| 13. | | C.J. Mosley LB, Alabama | Ha Ha Clinton-Dix FS, Alabama |
| 14. |  | Aaron Donald DT, Pittsburgh | Aaron Donald DT, Pittsburgh |
| 15. |  | Darqueze Dennard CB, Michigan State | Darqueze Dennard CB, Michigan St. |
| 16. |  | Timmy Jernigan DT, Florida State | Calvin Pryor FS, Louisville |
| 17. |  | Zack Martin OT, Notre Dame | Zack Martin OT, Notre Dame |
| 18. |  | Brandin Cooks WR, Oregon State | Marqise Lee WR, USC |
| 19. |  | Calvin Pryor S, Louisville | Taylor Lewan OT, Michigan |
| 20. |  | Odell Beckum WR, LSU | Dee Ford DE, Auburn |
| 21. |  | Marquise Lee WR, USC | Austin Seferian-Jenkins TE, Washington |
| 22. |  | Anthony Barr LB, UCLA | Odell Beckham WR, LSU |
| 23. |  | Kelvin Benjamin WR, Florida State | Brandin Cooks WR, Oregon St. |
| 24. |  | Justin Gilbert CB, Oklahoma State | Kony Ealy DE, Missouri |
| 25. |  | Kyle Fuller CB, Virginia Tech | Louis Nix NT, Notre Dame |
| 26. | | Jason Verrett CB, TCU | Derek Carr QB, Fresno St. |
| 27. |  | Jarvis Landry WR, LSU | Kyle Fuller CB, Virginia Tech |
| 28. |  | Joel Bitonio OT, Nevada | Jarvis Landry WR, LSU |
| 29. |  | Joel Bitonio OT, Nevada | Jarvis Landry WR, LSU |
| 30. |  | Lemarcus Joyner CB, Florida State | Timmy Jernigan NT, Florida St. |
| 31. |  | Chris Borland LB, Wisconsin | Jason Verrett CB, TCU |
| 32. |  | Xavier Su'a-Filo OG, UCLA | Xavier Su'a-Filo OG, UCLA |
